Communication Skills in the Age of AILebanese International University - School of Education

Chapter 7. Professionalism at Work in the Age of AI: Business Etiquette, Teamwork, and Meetings

In today’s AI- and technology-driven workplace, professionalism means much more than wearing a suit or using polite language. It includes virtual etiquette, digital collaboration, and responsible AI use. Professionals must be courteous and ethical both face-to-face and online, whether on a video call, in a group chat, or on social media. This chapter shows how respect, civility, and clear communication build trust and effectiveness, while incivility and carelessness can harm careers and organizations. Students will learn to behave thoughtfully in hybrid offices and remote teams, to give and receive feedback constructively, and to lead and participate in efficient, inclusive meetings. Throughout, we emphasize using AI and digital tools wisely (for example, drafting agendas or summarizing notes with AI) while retaining human judgment, empathy, and accountability.

Section Guide

Quick Self-Check

True / False 1

Professionalism includes etiquette, teamwork, meeting behavior, and responsible digital conduct.

True / False 2

Team meetings are successful only when one person talks most of the time.

Multiple Choice 1

Which action best supports productive teamwork?

Short Answer

Why is meeting preparation important?

Reveal answer
Answer: Preparation helps participants contribute meaningfully, stay focused on objectives, and use everyone’s time more effectively.

Chapter 7. Professionalism at Work in the Age of AI: Business Etiquette, Teamwork, and Meetings

In today’s AI- and technology-driven workplace, professionalism means much more than wearing a suit or using polite language. It includes virtual etiquette, digital collaboration, and responsible AI use. Professionals must be courteous and ethical both face-to-face and online, whether on a video call, in a group chat, or on social media. This chapter shows how respect, civility, and clear communication build trust and effectiveness, while incivility and carelessness can harm careers and organizations. Students will learn to behave thoughtfully in hybrid offices and remote teams, to give and receive feedback constructively, and to lead and participate in efficient, inclusive meetings. Throughout, we emphasize using AI and digital tools wisely (for example, drafting agendas or summarizing notes with AI) while retaining human judgment, empathy, and accountability.

Learning Outcomes

After studying this chapter, you will be able to:

  1. Describe what professionalism means on-site, online, and in hybrid work environments.
  2. Understand how incivility hurts organizations and how professional behavior reflects ethics and respect.
  3. Practice professional verbal communication: using vocal tone effectively, engaging in positive small talk, and handling criticism with composure.
  4. Use phone and voicemail (and voice notes) professionally, and manage mobile-device etiquette.
  5. Contribute positively to teams (in-person and virtual), recognize healthy vs. unhealthy team behaviors, and support psychological safety.
  6. Prepare for and participate in effective meetings, whether in a conference room or on Zoom/Teams, using agendas, active participation, and follow-up.
  7. Apply AI tools (like smart note-takers) responsibly to support collaboration and meeting productivity while safeguarding privacy and personal connection.

Opening Workplace ScenarioPriya, a new intern at a marketing firm, joins her first hybrid team meeting. She’s excited to use the company’s AI note-taking tool (Copilot) to transcribe and summarize the discussion. The meeting begins, but after a few minutes Priya notices her colleague Alex looking uncomfortable and her teammate Maria’s video frozen. Some attendees are off-camera or chatting privately. Priya sees her boss roll her eyes at a side conversation. Afterwards, Priya reviews the AI-generated summary and realizes it missed an important point about a customer’s feedback and captured a fragment of the rude side comment. She realizes that even with advanced AI tools, human awareness is crucial: she must follow up on the missed point herself, and speak up if she sees incivility. She decides to ask the team leader about best practices for virtual meetings and how to handle feedback from AI transcripts.

7-1. Developing Professionalism and Etiquette Skills On-Site and Online

Check for Understanding

Pause here and test the idea before moving on.

True / False

Professionalism includes etiquette, teamwork, meeting behavior, and responsible digital conduct.

Professionalism combines communication skill, courtesy, reliability, ethics, and adaptability. In modern work settings, it spans face-to-face, email, and virtual interactions. Employers say strong people skills and teamwork are top priorities. Conversely, a lack of professionalism—incivility—can be very costly. Surveys show that rude or disrespectful behavior is alarmingly common: U.S. workers report hundreds of millions of daily “acts of incivility” such as snippy emails and interruptions. This dysfunction carries a heavy price: organizations lose billions of dollars per day. For example, the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) estimates that uncivil workplace behavior costs U.S. businesses about $2.7 billion per day in lost productivity and absenteeism. On average, each rude incident costs a worker about 37 minutes of productivity and nearly two workdays off over a month. In short, incivility erodes morale and profits.

Embedded illustration
7-1a. Understanding Professionalism and the Cost of Incivility

Professional behavior is the antidote to these problems. Professionalism means civility: treating colleagues and clients with respect in words and actions. It means speaking and writing courteously, listening actively, and acknowledging others’ contributions. In a digital world, professionalism also includes being polite in emails, chat, and social media, and respecting others’ time (for instance, not double-booking meetings). Incivility, by contrast, includes gossip, dismissive comments, or failing to communicate important information (e.g., not notifying your team if you’ll miss work). For example, HR experts have noted that some young employees, having never held a job before, may fail to follow simple etiquette like calling in sick or responding to emails. When such uncivil behaviors occur—whether online or offline—they hurt everyone: they damage psychological safety and teamwork, and they distract from work. Organizations with civil cultures see better collaboration and retention.

Managing incivility is partly a leadership task: companies that model respectful behavior and set clear expectations tend to have healthier cultures. But individual employees also play a role by holding themselves to high standards of courtesy and accountability. Ultimately, professionalism is simply applied ethics in everyday work. It means honesty, fairness, and keeping confidences. For example, it’s unethical to delete emails to avoid scrutiny or to forward private conversations without permission. Professional ethics also covers digital behavior: don’t plagiarize on projects, don’t share confidential data with public AI tools, and don’t rely on AI or surveillance to judge coworkers. In each action—whether firing off an email, using Slack, or conducting a video call—ask, “Am I being fair and respectful?”

Embedded illustration
7-1b. Relating Professional Behavior to Ethics

Ethical behavior is a foundation of professionalism. At work, ethics means doing what’s right even when it’s hard or when no one is watching. This includes being honest with customers and colleagues, giving credit where it’s due, and following company policies. It also means respecting diversity and avoiding bias. For example, making a joke that offends someone’s background or posting something insensitive on social media can quickly damage trust. Modern workplaces emphasize inclusion and respect for all. That means using inclusive language (e.g., avoiding stereotypes or slurs) and considering others’ perspectives. Handling private information responsibly is a key ethical duty: don’t gossip about a colleague’s personal life, and safeguard customer data as you would your own.

Professional ethics extend to how we use technology. For instance, AI tools can help draft messages or analyze tone, but ethical users must verify any facts or suggestions the AI provides. If an AI suggests a claim or solution, the human must double-check its accuracy. Similarly, using an AI to monitor employee productivity (for example, tracking who finishes tasks fastest) raises privacy concerns and can undermine psychological safety. Responsible professionals will also be mindful of when to use AI: a heartfelt apology or feedback should be sincere and personalized, not obviously AI-generated or copied from a template. In sum, ethics shapes courtesy: it means acting with integrity and respect, fostering trust in all workplace interactions.

7-1c. Gaining an Etiquette Edge in a Networked World

Etiquette—knowing and practicing polite behaviors—gives you a career advantage. In the digital age, etiquette spans beyond handshake manners to online and hybrid settings. First impressions still count: arrive on time (even if the “meeting” is virtual), greet people by name, dress appropriately for the setting, and maintain a polite tone. On video calls, make sure your background is uncluttered and your camera and microphone work. When emailing or messaging, use a friendly yet professional greeting, and respond promptly (within a reasonable time, usually a day or two for emails).

Your online presence matters, too. Employers and clients often look at social media and LinkedIn profiles. Keep your social media profiles professional: think twice before posting controversial opinions on public platforms, because posts can be discovered. On LinkedIn, engage positively—comment thoughtfully and congratulate others on achievements, showing you’re a team player. This is digital etiquette and can set you apart as mature and conscientious.

At work, follow etiquette in all settings. For example, avoid interrupting someone’s video presentation to chat, silence your phone during meetings, and use workplace chat tools (like Slack or Teams) for quick, work-related questions rather than personal conversations. Handwritten notes still have power: sending a short thank-you email or a handwritten thank-you card after an interview or major meeting shows extra effort.

Embedded illustration

Professionalism CheckAre you consistently polite both on and off screen? Do you proofread your messages, listen actively to others, and show empathy? Keeping a good digital footprint and being punctual and courteous in all communications—whether on Zoom, in email, or even in a brief hallway chat—sets you apart as someone reliable and respectful. In today’s networked world, those skills are as important as technical know-how.

Embedded illustration

7-2. Communicating Face-to-Face on the Job

Check for Understanding

Use this quick checkpoint to make sure the section is clear.

Multiple Choice

Which action best supports productive teamwork?

Even with all the digital tools today, in-person communication remains a cornerstone of workplace professionalism. Face-to-face (and video) interactions build trust, convey nuance, and allow instant feedback. They are essential for sensitive discussions like performance feedback or brainstorming. This section covers how to use your voice and presence effectively in person or on video, how to engage in positive workplace conversation, and how to give and receive criticism constructively.

7-2a. Using Your Voice as a Communication Tool

Your voice—tone, volume, and clarity—carries much of your message beyond words. Studies suggest that up to 38% of communication impact comes from tone, pitch, and volume. This means that how you say something matters as much as what you say. To sound professional and confident: speak clearly and at a moderate pace; avoid mumbling or rushing. Adjust your volume so that you’re easy to hear without shouting. Vary your tone and emphasis to keep listeners engaged. For example, slowing down and lowering your pitch slightly can convey confidence and calmness, while a higher pitch or faster pace can seem anxious.

Avoid “uptalk” (ending statements with a rising intonation) which can make you sound uncertain. Practice good articulation: pronounce words fully, especially on video calls where poor audio can muffle speech. If you naturally speak very softly or quickly, conscious practice (or even recording yourself) can help you find a clear, steady pace.

Your body language and posture also interact with your voice. Stand or sit up straight, and face the person you’re speaking to. On video, look at the camera to simulate eye contact. Smiling slightly while speaking can improve the warmth of your tone. Remember that in virtual meetings, your mute/unmute and screen-sharing behavior become part of your “voice”: mute yourself to prevent background noise, and share your screen clearly so others can follow. In all cases, a respectful, confident tone underscores competence and helps your ideas be heard.

7-2b. Making Workplace Conversation Matter

Everyday conversations—small talk and casual office chat—may seem informal, but they are vital for building relationships. Professional, positive interaction is an important skill. Here are key principles:

  1. Use names and titles correctly. Address colleagues with the names or titles they prefer. In many cultures, it’s polite to use formal titles (Mr./Ms./Dr.) until invited to use first names. Starting a sentence with someone’s name (e.g., “Alex, could you explain…”) keeps conversation direct and personal.
  2. Choose appropriate topics. Safe subjects include work-related interests, industry news, or neutral personal interests (hobbies, weekend plans). Avoid politics, religion, or personal finances—topics that could cause friction. For instance, discuss a new project strategy rather than controversial news. Pay attention to social cues: if someone seems uncomfortable or changes the subject, gracefully move on.
  3. Listen actively. Genuine engagement builds trust. Show interest by nodding, making eye contact, and occasionally summarizing: “So you mean…”. Ask open-ended questions (who, what, when, how, why) to encourage others to share. For example, ask “How did you find the conference?” instead of yes/no questions. If talking in a group, include quieter members by asking their opinions by name.
  4. Be positive and inclusive. Give sincere compliments on others’ work or ideas. If you disagree, do it respectfully: “I see your point, and I wonder…” instead of outright dismissal. Use inclusive language (“we” and “our team”) rather than “I” all the time. Avoid interrupting or speaking over someone; let them finish their thought.
  5. Mind your manners in informal settings too. Don’t check your phone when someone is speaking to you. If you must step out of a meeting or call for a moment, briefly excuse yourself. In hallway chats, keep a comfortable distance and follow any COVID-era practices (some workplaces still encourage masks or distancing, so respect the current norms).

Workplace ExampleImagine you’re in the office kitchen waiting for coffee. A colleague is nearby, looking stressed. Instead of scrolling on your phone, you might say, “Hi Jordan, how’s your day?” This simple gesture can brighten their mood and strengthen rapport. By contrast, brushing past them without greeting might seem curt. Small acts of courtesy accumulate into a professional reputation.

7-2c. Receiving Workplace Criticism Gracefully

Everyone makes mistakes; receiving criticism well is a key professional skill. When someone offers feedback or points out an issue, focus on learning rather than reacting. Here’s how to handle it gracefully:

  1. Listen without interrupting. Give the speaker your full attention. Avoid fidgeting or checking devices while being told something, even if it’s uncomfortable. Show you’re listening with nods or brief verbal acknowledgments (e.g., “I understand”).
  2. Manage emotions. It’s natural to feel defensive if criticized. Take a deep breath and remind yourself that the goal is improvement. Silence is okay for a moment if you need to process. Try not to react with a hostile tone or sarcasm.
  3. Clarify and paraphrase. If the feedback is unclear, ask polite questions. For example, “Can you give an example?” or “So, if I understand, you’re concerned that…?” Restating the points confirms you understand and shows respect.
  4. Avoid excuses. Defensiveness can undermine rapport. Instead of blaming others or circumstances, focus on what you can do next. If you disagree, do so tactfully: “I see why it might look like that. However, let me explain my perspective…” and offer facts calmly.
  5. Acknowledge valid points. If the criticism is fair, say something like “Thank you for pointing that out. I’ll make sure to fix this.” Accept responsibility for mistakes; it demonstrates maturity. For instance, “You’re right, I should have double-checked the data. I apologize, and I’ll correct it by tomorrow.”
  6. Ask for guidance if needed. “What do you suggest I do differently?” or “How can I improve this?” These questions turn criticism into constructive dialogue and show willingness to learn.

Receiving feedback in person or on video can be easier to navigate, since tone and expressions are visible. Even over email or chat, try to respond with a calm, professional tone. If a written critique feels particularly harsh or unclear, consider asking to discuss it in person or via call. Remember that criticism, when delivered professionally, is often meant to help you grow. Keeping your response respectful preserves goodwill and your professional image.

7-2d. Providing Constructive Criticism on the Job

Giving feedback is as important as receiving it. When done respectfully, it helps coworkers improve and builds trust. Keep these tips in mind:

  1. Prepare your message. Think about the goal and main points before speaking. If possible, schedule a private conversation rather than giving feedback in front of others. If it’s a formal situation, like a performance review, follow a recognized model (e.g., Situation–Behavior–Impact: describe the situation, the person’s behavior, and its effect).
  2. Start positively or neutrally. If appropriate, begin with something positive or at least neutral. For example: “I appreciate your effort on this report” or “Thanks for meeting to discuss this.” Then gently introduce the issue. A short appreciative buffer can soften the message.
  3. Focus on behavior, not character. Discuss what the person did, not who they are. Say “The project was late” instead of “You are always late.” Use specific observations: “In yesterday’s meeting, I noticed you interrupted John while he was speaking.”
  4. Be specific and factual. Vague feedback is unhelpful. Point to a concrete example and explain the impact. For instance: “The last email you sent had a typo in the report figures, which caused confusion for the client.” This clarifies exactly what went wrong and why it matters.
  5. Use a supportive tone. Speak in a calm, even tone. Avoid accusatory or harsh language. You might say, “Let’s work together on this” or “I’d like to help you improve.” Use “we” to share ownership.
  6. Offer solutions or ask for their input. Suggest concrete steps: “Next time, could you double-check the numbers?” Or invite them: “How can we prevent this in the future?” This engages the person in finding a fix and avoids a one-sided lecture.
  7. End on a positive note. Reaffirm your confidence in the person’s ability: “I know you can handle this with attention to detail,” or “Thanks for hearing me out; I appreciate your effort.”

AI at WorkAI can help draft feedback. For example, you might prompt an AI tool with the situation and ask for a tactful suggestion: “An employee missed a deadline because he forgot to notify the team. How can I say this constructively?” The AI might generate a gentle phrasing, which you can then personalize. Always review AI drafts carefully: remove any language that sounds too clinical or generic. Ensure the final feedback reflects your authentic voice and the specifics of the situation. Never rely solely on AI to handle sensitive conversations; use it as a writing aid, then add personal empathy.

Embedded illustration
7-3. Following Phone and Voice Mail Best Practices

Check for Understanding

Try answering before opening the model response.

Short Answer

Why is meeting preparation important?

Reveal answer
Answer: Preparation helps participants contribute meaningfully, stay focused on objectives, and use everyone’s time more effectively.

Voice communication (phone calls and voice mails) remains important for urgent, complex, or personal conversations. Even in a chatty office or with email so common, picking up the phone can quickly resolve misunderstandings. Here we cover making and receiving calls, plus modern mobile etiquette.

7-3a. Making Phone Calls Professionally

Before calling, have a purpose. If possible, plan a brief mini-agenda or opening line in your mind. When the person answers:

  1. Identify yourself and state purpose. For example: “Hello, this is Maria Ortiz from HR. I’m calling to discuss the details of the new policy.” This orients the listener immediately.

Be concise but courteous. Get to the point politely. If it’s a quick question, ask it after introductions. If it’s longer, give a one-sentence summary: “I wanted to check on the timeline for the project you mentioned.”

Use a friendly tone. Smiling while speaking (even on the phone) makes your voice sound warmer. Keep background noise low, and speak clearly. Adjust volume so you don’t shout but can be heard easily.

  1. Listen actively. Let the other person speak without interrupting. Use verbal nods (“I see,” “Sure,” “Thank you”) to show you’re engaged.

Clarify next steps. Before ending, recap any decisions: “So we will send the report by Friday, and I’ll email you the draft tomorrow.” Confirm understanding: “Does that work for you?”

Polite closing. Thank them: “Thank you for your time,” and say goodbye: “Have a great day.”

If the call goes to voicemail, leave a clear, brief message. State your name, organization, and purpose (and your phone number twice slowly, if voice mail may garble numbers). For example: “Hello Alex, this is Priya from marketing. I’m calling about the slides you requested for next week’s meeting. Please call me back at 555-1234. Thank you.” Speak at a steady pace and smile while talking; it helps even over a recording.

7-3b. Receiving Phone Calls Professionally

When receiving a call:

  1. Answer promptly. Within 2-3 rings is polite. Let it ring past 3 to avoid answering too quickly (which sounds like you might have anticipated it).
  2. Identify yourself. If at work, say your full name and department: “Hello, this is Daniel Lee in IT Support.” This avoids confusion if the caller isn’t sure who they reached.
  3. Be attentive and helpful. If you’re unsure who the caller wants, politely ask: “May I ask whom I’m speaking with?” or “Are you calling about the marketing project?” If you can’t answer their question, offer to connect them or find out. For example, “I’m not certain, but let me check on that and get back to you.”
  4. Take messages carefully. If the call is for someone else and they are unavailable, ask the caller for their name, number, and a brief reason for calling. Write it down clearly, noting the time of call. Example: “I’ll let Maria know you called and ask her to return your call by 3 pm.”
  5. Protect privacy. If it’s a busy area, you may step aside or ask to call back to ensure confidentiality. Don’t repeat sensitive details out loud.

If the call is from an unknown number or salesperson and you’re busy, you can say, “I’m sorry, I’m not available to talk right now. Could you email me instead?” or take a polite message.

7-3c. Using Mobile Phones in Business

Smartphones blur work and personal life. Use them wisely:

  1. Notifications and availability. Turn on Do Not Disturb during focused work or meetings, except for VIP or emergency contacts. This avoids interruptions.
  2. Camera etiquette. Before recording video or photos at work (e.g., event photos, whiteboard notes), ensure it’s allowed and that people consent. Some companies ban recording meetings without permission. Always check first.
  3. Messaging apps. Workplace messaging (Slack, Teams, WhatsApp) is convenient, but follow norms: keep chats concise and professional. Respect after-hours: only message late if it’s urgent, and consider setting status messages (“Out of office until 9 AM”).
  4. “Phubbing” (phone snubbing). Don’t text or browse your phone during face-to-face interactions. For example, in a meeting or casual chat, give your attention to colleagues rather than looking at your screen.
  5. Appropriate use. Personal browsing or games should be kept to breaks and never during meetings or in place of work duties.

A good rule: imagine your boss or mentor is watching. If you wouldn’t do it in front of them, don’t do it on your phone at work.

Embedded illustration

7-3d. Making the Best Use of Voice Mail

Modern voicemails often get transcribed to text, so clarity is key. Best practices:

  1. Professional greeting. If you have a business voicemail, record a clear, brief greeting with your name and company: “You’ve reached John Smith at Acme Corp. I’m not available to take your call right now. Please leave your name, number, and a short message, and I will return your call as soon as I can.”
  2. Concise messages. When leaving a message, speak slowly and state your purpose upfront (as shown in section 7-3a). Keep it to 30-60 seconds.
  3. Check the transcription. If your voicemail system provides a text transcript, read it to ensure it’s accurate. Sometimes AI transcripts get confused. If there’s an error (e.g. misheard number), follow up with an email or text to clarify.
  4. Follow up. If you leave a voicemail, follow up by email or chat referencing the call. For example: “I left you a voicemail regarding the budget report. I’ll email the details in case you missed it.” This ensures the recipient has the information.

Professionalism CheckAre your calls clear, prompt, and considerate? Do you check your voicemail and follow up? Using voicemail or phone well ensures important information isn’t missed and shows you respect others’ time. In emergencies, a quick call often beats a chat message.

Embedded illustration

7-4. Succeeding in Professional Teams

Teams—groups of people working together—are central to most organizations today. They pool diverse skills to solve problems and innovate. With the rise of remote and hybrid work, teams now span offices, countries, and time zones. Effective team members contribute ideas, communicate openly, and support each other. Let’s explore how teams function and how you can thrive in them.

7-4a. Understanding the Purpose of Teams

Teams are formed to achieve goals that single individuals can’t easily reach. When well-managed, teams enhance decision-making, creativity, and engagement. For example, a cross-functional project team brings together marketing, engineering, and finance to launch a new product—each member adds a unique perspective. Research shows that face-to-face collaboration spurs innovation and productivity, and teams that feel psychologically safe (comfortable sharing ideas without judgment) produce more creative solutions.

However, teams can falter if not structured well. Common pitfalls include unclear goals, overlapping roles, or lack of trust. Without leadership, meetings can devolve into side conversations or domination by a few. A team’s strength lies in shared purpose and mutual respect. High-performing teams typically: define a clear mission, assign roles, set expectations, and hold each other accountable. For example, at the start, team members might agree on communication rules (when to use chat vs. email, meeting frequency) and document these norms.

Teamwork today also means blending on-site and remote members. Hybrid teams can leverage the best of both worlds—face-to-face bonding and flexible remote work—but need extra coordination (see section 7-5). Successful teams establish psychological safety: members treat mistakes as learning opportunities, and leaders encourage open discussion. Google’s research famously found that teams with high psychological safety outperformed others. In practice, that means if a project is behind schedule, a teammate feels safe admitting it and asking for help, rather than hiding the problem.

7-4b. Working Remotely: The Rise of Virtual Teams

Remote and hybrid teams are now common. Virtual teams rely on digital collaboration tools like Slack, Teams, Google Docs, Trello, and Zoom. They allow people across locations to work together nearly as if in the same room. The advantages include flexible schedules and access to talent worldwide. But remote work also poses challenges: miscommunication (no body language cues), feelings of isolation, and overwork (it’s harder to “leave” work at home).

To succeed in a virtual team:

  1. Overcommunicate and clarify. In email or chat, be explicit. For instance, instead of saying “soon,” give a date: “I’ll send it by Tuesday.” Use short, clear sentences. When chatting, confirm understanding (“Got it, I’ll send the draft by 3pm”).
  2. Use rich media appropriately. Video calls and voice chats convey tone and build rapport. Schedule occasional video check-ins to see faces and hear voices. Use screen sharing or collaborative docs to work together live. Save email for things that need a written record.
  3. Embrace asynchronous work. Team members in different time zones may need to wait for responses. Use shared task boards or status updates to show progress. Write meeting notes (section 7-5) so others can catch up.
  4. Build trust. On virtual teams, you must often be explicit about reliability. If you commit to a deadline, meet it. If delays occur, communicate early. Recognize teammates’ efforts—post a thank-you in chat or highlight contributions in team meetings.
  5. Watch for burnout. Remote workers may skip breaks or work long hours. Encourage your team to take time off and respect “offline” times (e.g., avoid scheduling calls at midnight for someone).

For inclusion, make sure remote colleagues are heard: if a meeting is half in-person, use headsets for those on video, and don’t let chat comments go unnoticed. Share meeting notes and recordings promptly (see 7-5d). Technology helps: project-management tools (Asana, Jira) and document sharing keep everyone aligned. But be mindful: don’t overload team chat with irrelevant pings. Keep messages work-related or positively social, and use threads or channels to organize topics.

Embedded illustration

7-4c. Recognizing Positive and Negative Team Behavior

Healthy teams exhibit positive behaviors: members set clear roles and deadlines, contribute ideas openly, and give credit to colleagues. During discussions, they actively listen, build on others’ suggestions, and encourage quieter members to speak. They also handle conflict constructively (see next section) and celebrate team successes together.

Unproductive behaviors to avoid include:

  1. Dominating conversations. If one person interrupts or “mansplains” an idea, others may withdraw. Instead, participants should take turns and use signals (raising a hand in video calls) to contribute.
  2. Withdrawing or silence. Quiet members might have valuable input. Effective teams invite them: “I’d love to hear your thoughts, Priya.”
  3. Excessive negativity. Constant complaining or finger-pointing poisons morale. If you have a criticism, phrase it constructively (as in 7-2d).
  4. Blaming or gossiping. If something goes wrong, blaming others or workplace gossip damages trust. Instead, focus on fixing the problem.
  5. Procrastination or missing deadlines. If you know you’ll miss a deadline, inform the team immediately and suggest alternatives. Keeping silent only creates bigger crises later.
  6. Ignoring team norms. For instance, if the team agreed to summarize meetings in a shared doc, always do your part. Skipping agreed-upon processes frustrates others.
  7. Excessive reliance on AI or tools alone. AI tools can help with drafting or analysis, but don’t use them as a crutch that prevents human collaboration. For example, blindly trusting an AI meeting summary (instead of reviewing it) might miss nuances.

Positive Team Example: In a virtual product design team, Sam starts each morning by updating their Trello board with tasks, so everyone sees progress. His teammate Lisa consistently checks the Slack channel and answers questions promptly. When a disagreement arises on design direction, they hold a video meeting (not vent in email) and openly discuss pros and cons. The team also does a quick icebreaker or shares successes at the start of meetings to maintain camaraderie. These behaviors—clarity, responsiveness, collaboration—keep the team effective.

Embedded illustration

7-4d. Identifying Successful Teams

Research and practice show that successful teams share these traits:

  1. Clear goals and roles. Every member knows the team’s purpose and their individual responsibilities. They have a shared plan or timeline.
  2. Open communication. They discuss issues honestly and listen respectfully. Regular check-ins (standups or status updates) keep everyone informed.
  3. Psychological safety. As noted earlier, members feel safe sharing ideas without fear of ridicule. Leaders encourage questions and admit their own mistakes.
  4. Constructive conflict. Rather than avoiding disagreements, strong teams debate ideas respectfully. They focus on problem-solving, not personal attacks.
  5. Collaboration and support. Team members help each other learn new skills, share resources (like delegating tasks), and collectively celebrate wins.
  6. Accountability and trust. Each person follows through on commitments. When someone struggles, others pitch in. Trust grows from consistent reliability.
  7. Adaptability. Good teams can pivot when plans change or new information emerges. They update goals and methods as needed.
  8. Inclusion and diversity. High-performing teams leverage diverse perspectives. Inclusion means everyone’s voice is welcomed and valued.

As an individual, you contribute to these qualities by communicating clearly, being dependable, and showing respect. For example, if you disagree in a meeting, do so politely and offer alternatives. If a teammate makes a mistake, help correct it rather than criticize. Celebrate team achievements (a thank-you note after a successful launch, for instance) to reinforce positivity. By practicing professional behaviors daily, you help build a team culture where everyone can do their best work.

Embedded illustration

Professionalism CheckAre you following through on what you commit to and giving credit to others? Are you flexible when plans change? Remember: teams rely on each member’s professionalism. Small actions—like updating shared documents, responding on time, and acknowledging a colleague’s idea—make a big difference in team success.

7-5. Making the Most of Face-to-Face and Virtual Meetings

Meetings are a major part of professional life. Done well, they align teams and spark ideas; done poorly, they waste time and cause frustration. With many meetings now hybrid or fully virtual, new skills are needed. This section guides you through the full meeting cycle: preparation, management, and follow-up, for both in-person and online meetings.

Embedded illustration
7-5a. Preparing for the Meeting

Successful meetings start long before people join the room or video call.

  1. Determine necessity. Not every topic needs a meeting. Could an email, a quick chat, or a shared doc do the job? People report spending hours in unnecessary meetings. Before you schedule, ask if it’s truly needed.
  2. Define purpose and agenda. If a meeting is justified, define a clear purpose: is it a decision meeting, brainstorm, status update, or training? Then create a simple agenda listing items, approximate times, and roles (e.g., presenter, note-taker). For example, “Agenda: 1) Review sales figures (Jane), 2) Brainstorm marketing ideas (All), 3) Next steps”. Distribute the agenda (and any pre-reading materials) at least a day in advance so attendees can prepare.
  3. Invite the right people. Limit the invite list to those who really need to be there (“invite-only” keeps meetings focused). For larger topics, consider a short “info-sharing” meeting versus working sessions.
  4. Set roles. Assign a moderator or facilitator to guide the meeting and a scribe for notes. In hybrid settings, consider a remote co-facilitator who watches the chat and ensures remote participants are included. For example, the remote facilitator can say, “I see Priya raised her hand in Zoom—Priya, go ahead.”
  5. Check logistics. If in person, book a room with necessary equipment. If virtual, ensure the video link works and is shared. Test tech beforehand: is the internet reliable? Is the conference line ready? If using a tool like Microsoft Teams or Zoom, check that screen sharing and audio work. Get consent for recording. If you plan to use AI transcription or record the meeting, inform participants in advance (this may be legally required or simply polite).
  6. Send reminders. A short email reminder on the day of the meeting with time, place/link, and agenda helps everyone arrive on time and prepared.

Embedded illustration
7-5b. Managing the Meeting

During the meeting, good facilitation keeps things on track:

  1. Start on time. Begin promptly whether everyone’s there or not. If some are late, recaps can be done later.
  2. Open clearly. State the meeting’s purpose and agenda again. For example: “Our goal today is to finalize the launch plan. First, we’ll review progress; second, brainstorm tasks; third, assign next steps.” This orients all participants.
  3. Establish ground rules. Quickly agree on norms: will cameras be on? How to signal wanting to speak? Remind people to mute microphones when not talking to avoid noise. If participants join from an office setting, ask everyone to one-by-one speak clearly into the microphone.
  4. Balance participation. Make sure everyone can contribute. In hybrid meetings, alternate between in-room and remote voices. For example, after an in-person team member speaks, the facilitator might say, “What do our colleagues on video think?” Watch the chat for raised-hand emojis or comments. If someone seems overlooked, call on them by name politely.
  5. Keep focus and energy. Stick to the agenda. If someone veers off-topic, gently steer back: “These are great ideas, but maybe we can table that for our next meeting so we don’t run out of time.” For complex or heated items, break them down step-by-step and encourage fact-based discussion.
  6. Use visual aids effectively. If brainstorming, share a digital whiteboard or survey tool everyone can use. Avoid turning your back to the camera if writing on a physical board. Clearly narrate any shared content (“on screen you’ll see…”).
  7. Monitor time. Assign someone (or use a timer app) to ensure each item doesn’t overrun. Summarize and move on if a topic is done.
  8. Summarize key points throughout. As discussion concludes on an item, recap decisions and action items. For example: “To confirm, we decided to order 500 units, and Maria will finalize the specs by Tuesday.” This ensures clarity for both in-person and remote attendees.
  9. Encourage questions and feedback. Especially invite remote attendees to ask questions. Pause periodically: “Any questions so far?” or “Is everyone comfortable with this decision?” This is important for inclusion.

7-5c. Concluding the Meeting and Following Up

The meeting isn’t over when people log off or leave the room. Follow-up turns discussion into action:

  1. Confirm action items. At the end, quickly list what tasks were assigned to whom and by when. Check everyone’s understanding: “So John will email the report by Friday, and Sara will reach out to the vendor by end of day?” This verification ensures accountability.
  2. Review decisions. Restate any key decisions: “We’re all clear that the deadline moves to June 30.” This helps the meeting objectives to stick.
  3. Thank participants. Ending on a positive note (“Thanks everyone for the productive meeting”) shows appreciation for their time.
  4. Distribute meeting notes quickly. Send out the minutes or a summary within 24 hours. Include decisions, action items (with responsible persons and deadlines), and any relevant links or documents. This is crucial for those who couldn’t attend and for hybrid teams where some may have missed parts of the conversation. If you used an AI transcription tool, review it first: AI can save time capturing everything, but you should edit the raw transcript into concise notes.
  5. Follow up on tasks. Don’t let action items languish. It’s often helpful to send reminders or check-ins. For example, an email reminder a week later: “Hi team, just a reminder that we’re waiting on the draft report from John by tomorrow.”
  6. Gather feedback on the meeting itself. Occasionally ask participants how the meeting format is working (especially if it’s a large or hybrid group). Were the objectives clear? Could any part have been done via email? Use quick polls or a chat question: “Did this meeting meet your expectations? Any improvements?”
  • Embedded illustration

AI at WorkAI tools can help here. For example, prompt an AI to summarize a meeting transcript or draft a follow-up email: “Summarize key points from yesterday’s project meeting.” But remember: always review and refine AI-generated text. It may miss context or include mistakes. Use your judgment to ensure the summary is clear and accurate. And use AI reminders responsibly: you might set a calendar reminder via AI, but personally send the check-in so it feels genuine.

Embedded illustration

7-5d. Interacting in Zoom, Teams, and Other Virtual Meetings

Virtual meetings have their own etiquette norms:

  1. Test your setup. Before joining, check your camera, microphone, and internet. Use a quiet, well-lit environment so colleagues can see and hear you clearly. A plain background or subtle virtual background helps keep the focus on you. Wear appropriate attire (basically what you’d wear to an in-person meeting).
  2. Display names. Use your real name (or company handles) so people recognize you. Avoid nicknames or impolite usernames.
  3. Mute when not speaking. Background noise (typing, pets) can disrupt others. Keep yourself muted unless talking. Remember to unmute before you start speaking.
  4. Camera etiquette. If bandwidth allows, turn on your camera for more personal connection. At least keep it on when speaking. If you need to step away briefly, either turn off your camera or let the others know: “Briefly, I have someone at the door.” However, it’s okay to turn off video if your Internet is unstable or if you’re eating (just mute!).
  5. Stay engaged. Avoid multitasking (no checking email or scrolling on your phone). Show you’re listening by nodding or giving brief verbal cues (“yes,” “I agree”). If someone presents slides or shares their screen, don’t chat in an unrelated channel simultaneously; it can cause missed messages or confusion.
  6. Use chat professionally. The in-meeting chat can be useful for quick comments or questions. If you have a question but someone else is talking, type it in chat. Avoid private side conversations; they can be distracting and unkind to the group. Keep chat messages concise and relevant. If you need to add something off-topic, save it for the end or a separate conversation.
  7. Turn-taking. In virtual meetings, people often talk over each other. Use features like “Raise Hand” or a chat message to indicate you wish to speak. Wait for the moderator to call on you or say your name before unmuting.
  8. Be inclusive. Address remote participants directly by name to ensure they feel included (“Emily and Raj, what are your thoughts?”). Encourage those who haven’t spoken to contribute.
  9. Respect time zones. If teammates are in different locations, schedule meetings at reasonable hours for everyone if possible. If a meeting does fall outside someone’s normal hours, rotate times so the inconvenience is shared. Don’t assume others can reply instantly if it’s past their working hours.
  10. Captions and accessibility. Many tools offer live captioning. If someone has a hearing impairment or if there’s heavy accent, captions can help. Provide transcripts afterwards if possible.
  11. Recording and transcription consent. Always announce at the start if the meeting is being recorded or transcribed (especially if using AI). Give people a chance to object or opt out. For instance: “We’re recording this meeting for reference. Please let us know if that’s a problem.” Be mindful of privacy regulations and company policy.
Embedded illustration

Hybrid Meeting ReminderIf some participants are together in a conference room and others remote, place the camera so it shows all in-room people. Speak clearly and direct questions to remote attendees by name, so they don’t feel left out. For example, say “Let’s pause here. Remote team, any feedback on these ideas?” rather than discussing only in-room.

Summary of Learning Outcomes
  1. Define professionalism and its components (civility, ethics, etiquette) in both physical and digital workplaces.
  2. Explain how unprofessional behavior (incivility) harms employees and organizations (loss of time, money, morale).
  3. Apply professional communication skills in person: clear speech, active listening, positive small talk, and courteous body language.
  4. Practice making and receiving phone calls and voicemails appropriately, and manage smartphone etiquette.
  5. Participate effectively in teams: contribute ideas, respect norms, support psychological safety, and collaborate with remote members.
  6. Plan and facilitate productive meetings (setting agendas, engaging participants, summarizing decisions) whether in a room or online.
  7. Use AI tools (e.g., transcription, drafting) to support etiquette and efficiency, while maintaining empathy, confidentiality, and clear human oversight.

Key Terms

Professionalism
Conducting oneself with responsibility, integrity, and courtesy in the workplace.
Business Etiquette
Accepted polite behaviors and manners in professional settings (including greetings, dress, and communication style).
Civility
Polite, respectful behavior that promotes a positive work environment.
Incivility
Rude or discourteous actions (e.g., interrupting, sarcasm) that undermine collaboration.
Soft skills
Personal attributes like communication, adaptability, and teamwork that enhance professional interactions.
Emotional Intelligence
Awareness of one’s own emotions and others’ emotions, used to manage communication effectively.
Ethics
Principles of right and wrong; in work, this means honesty, fairness, and confidentiality.
Digital Professionalism
Applying professional standards and etiquette in online and digital interactions.
Digital Footprint
The trail of data and information (social media posts, online profiles) that one leaves on the internet.
Constructive Criticism
Feedback given with the intention of helping someone improve, delivered respectfully and specifically.
Feedback
Information about performance or behavior given to help someone grow.
Phone Etiquette
Best practices for business calls (clear introductions, concise messages, active listening).
Voice Mail
Recorded message left for an unavailable person; requires clear delivery of name, purpose, and contact info.
Mobile Etiquette
Appropriate use of smartphones at work (e.g., silencing in meetings, discreet texting).
Team
A group of people working interdependently toward a common goal.
Virtual Team
A team whose members collaborate primarily through technology rather than in person.
Hybrid Team
A team with some members working on-site and others remotely.
Psychological Safety
A team climate where members feel safe taking risks and expressing ideas without fear of negative consequences.
Conflict Resolution
Methods for resolving disagreements in a professional, respectful manner.
Agenda
A structured outline of topics and goals for a meeting.
Meeting Minutes
A written summary of a meeting’s decisions, action items, and key points.
Action Items
Tasks assigned to team members during or after a meeting.
Virtual Meeting Etiquette
Best practices for video/audio conferences (e.g., muting when not speaking).
AI Note-Taker
A tool that transcribes or summarizes meetings; must be checked for accuracy and privacy.
Chapter Review Questions
  1. Definitional: What is workplace professionalism, and how does it differ from basic politeness?
    Possible answer: A strong response should define the concept accurately in your own words and include at least one clear workplace example from the chapter.
  2. Conceptual: Why do experts say that incivility at work costs companies billions of dollars? Give two examples of how rude behavior can harm productivity or morale.
    Possible answer: A strong response should explain the reasoning step by step, support it with chapter ideas, and include a concrete example or application.
  3. Practical: List three ways you can show respect to a coworker during a face-to-face interaction and three ways to show respect in a digital interaction (email or chat).
    Possible answer: A strong response should explain the reasoning step by step, support it with chapter ideas, and include a concrete example or application.
  4. Procedural: What steps should you take before, during, and after a meeting to ensure it is productive?
    Possible answer: A strong response should use the chapter’s concepts, apply them to the situation, and support the answer with a clear example.
  5. Analytical: How does psychological safety influence team performance? What can team members do to create a psychologically safe environment?
    Possible answer: A strong response should explain the reasoning step by step, support it with chapter ideas, and include a concrete example or application.
  6. Technical: What are the advantages and pitfalls of using an AI transcription service for meetings?
    Possible answer: A strong response should define the concept accurately in your own words and include at least one clear workplace example from the chapter.
  7. Ethical: If you overhear a colleague making a biased remark online (e.g., in a workplace chat), how should you respond as a professional?
    Possible answer: A strong response should explain the reasoning step by step, support it with chapter ideas, and include a concrete example or application.
References
(APA 7th edition)
Colvin, C. (2023, December 5). Employers, educators are filling in Gen Z’s etiquette gap. HR Dive.
GMAC. (2023). What skills are employers looking for in 2023? [Survey report]. GMAC.
Lichtenberg, N. (2025, August 31). Business loses $2.1 billion a day from office rudeness, study says. Fortune.
Project Aristotle. (2024, March 28). Google’s Project Aristotle: psychological safety in teams. PsychSafety.com.
SHRM. (2024). The cost of incivility: Workplace challenges into 2025 [Insights article]. Society for Human Resource Management.
Tsipursky, G. (2023, August 6). Rules for hybrid work etiquette. Forbes. [Restricted access]
Work Trend Index. (2024). Annual work trend index. Microsoft News.

Notes

Save your own reflections, answer drafts, or reminders for Chapter 7. Professionalism at Work in the Age of AI: Business Etiquette, Teamwork, and Meetings.